Mauricio Pochettino Takes Over at Manchester United: The Six Problems Waiting for Him at Old Trafford
Mauricio Pochettino is the new Manchester United manager, and he walks into a club in a mess. Michael Carrick has left the job barely seven months after signing a two-year contract as permanent boss.
United finished third in the Premier League last season. They have since slid so far that, the club is now in real relegation danger sitting in the 18th position with only 8 points. Pochettino’s first game is a big one: a trip to Anfield to face Liverpool once the international break ends.
This post draws on Goal’s analysis by James Westwood. The opinions below belong to that report, not to Rex News Ug.
The bigger picture behind the job
The report argues that the problems run deeper than any one manager. It points to the Glazer family’s ownership, the club’s heavy debt and the money paid out in loan interest and dividends. INEOS bought a minority stake and took charge of football operations in early 2024, but the report says the debt burden has not gone away.
There is talk that the Glazers may be ready to sell. They began a sale process in November 2022 and then stepped back from a full sale. The report’s view is that Pochettino can start building something, but he cannot fix a long-term project on his own.
Problem one: the defence
United have conceded 19 goals in 10 Premier League games this season, the third-worst record in the league.
Left-back is the weak spot the report highlights first. Luke Shaw, 31, has missed United’s last seven matches with a muscle problem. With no natural replacement, Carrick moved Diogo Dalot over from the right. The report says that went badly, with Dalot caught out of position and involved in several costly mistakes.
Noussair Mazraoui is a right-back by trade, and Patrick Dorgu is more of a winger. The report notes that United spent about £150 million on their midfield in the summer without adding another full-back. It says Fulham’s Calvin Bassey is already reportedly on United’s radar.
Centre-back has its own fitness and experience issues:
- Harry Maguire, 33, went off at half-time in last weekend’s 4-4 draw with Aston Villa.
- Carrick replaced him with 20-year-old Ayden Heaven, who partnered Leny Yoro, also 20.
- Matthijs de Ligt, 27, was on the bench but is still returning from almost a year out with a back injury.
- Lisandro Martinez has had injury problems and came under pressure after speaking out against the club’s hierarchy following a poor display at Atletico Madrid in October. His contract runs out next summer.
The report says Brentford’s Nathan Collins and Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite have both been linked with United. These are reports only. Nothing has been confirmed by the club.
The report also makes a point about Pochettino’s record. It lists Shaw, Harry Kane, Dele Alli, Eric Dier, Kyle Walker, Cole Palmer and Conor Gallagher as players who improved under him at various clubs.
Problem two: a midfield that doesn’t fit together
United brought in Youri Tielemans, Carlos Baleba and Andrey Santos over the summer, and the report says the midfield still doesn’t work. Kobbie Mainoo is the first choice in the double pivot, which leaves one of Baleba or Santos on the bench. Casemiro’s goal threat and aerial presence have not been replaced.
The bigger squeeze is in the No.10 role. Tielemans fits best there, but that is Bruno Fernandes’ position, and Fernandes was last season’s PFA Player of the Year. When Carrick tried to fit both in, he pushed Fernandes wide or into a false nine role. The report says United looked more disjointed for it.
Against Villa, Unai Emery’s team went through United’s midfield repeatedly, and the report says Tielemans’ lack of recovery pace was exposed. Tielemans and Mainoo were also too far from Fernandes as he pressed.
One possible fix is the 4-3-3 that Pochettino used regularly at past clubs. Baleba could sit in front of the defence, with Fernandes and Mainoo free to go forward. The report says that would make United more compact in the middle and push opponents wide.
Problem three: no obvious striker
United have plenty of attacking options out wide. Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha and Amad Diallo are all there, and teenage winger Shea Lacey is pushing for minutes.
Down the middle, though, the report says the picture is thin. Benjamin Sesko, signed for £74 million, scored 11 league goals last season, level with Mbeumo as United’s joint-top scorer. He hurt his shin in May and then suffered a flare-up in the Carabao Cup defeat to Brighton in September. He has been ruled out until the new year.
Carrick did not trust Joshua Zirkzee as cover, so he rotated Cunha and Mbeumo through the No.9 role. The report says neither suits it. Cunha likes to drop deep, and Mbeumo is at his best cutting in from the right.
Names mentioned as possible targets include Leeds’ Dominic Calvert-Lewin, Al-Ahli’s Ivan Toney and Fulham’s Rodrigo Muniz. These are reports only.
Problem four: who stays and who goes
The report expects Pochettino to want a say over who leaves in January. Marcus Rashford is a key example. He was loaned to Aston Villa and Barcelona under Ruben Amorim, then returned over the summer. The report says moving him on would free up more than £300,000 a week in wages.
The same report suggests Martinez, Mason Mount, Manuel Ugarte, Zirkzee, Shaw and Dalot could also be moved on. That is the report’s view, not a club decision. United have not announced any exits.
Problem five: effort and fitness
This is the part of the report that reads hardest for the players. It says United rank 19th in the Premier League for total running distance, at 102.38 kilometres per 90 minutes under Carrick. It says they are bottom for sprints and total sprint time.
Tielemans said before the season that pre-season training did not involve much running. United were then outworked by newly promoted Hull City on the opening weekend, the report says.
Gary Neville was also blunt after United’s 1-1 draw at Fulham. He said the start to the second half was the worst 15 minutes he had seen as a United fan, and he criticised the players for walking when Fulham had the ball.
Pochettino’s teams are known for intensity. Rickie Lambert, who played under him at Southampton, told The Athletic the demands were tough at first but left him in the best shape of his career. The report concludes that this is exactly the shake-up United need.
What happens next
The immediate test is Anfield after the international break. The January window follows, when Pochettino is expected to get his first chance to reshape the squad.
The report says a top-five finish is the realistic aim if United want to salvage the season. Whether Pochettino gets the backing to make the changes is still unclear.
Do you think Pochettino can turn United around? Tell us in the comments, and follow Rex News Ug for the latest on the Anfield game and the January window.


